top of page

Is It Rude If I...? Holiday Edition

Nov 5
6 min read

The holidays bring plenty of etiquette questions, and so many of them start with "Is it rude if I...?"


Behind many of these questions is someone trying to set boundaries, figure out how to handle an awkward situation, or manage the expectations that come with the holidays. And when we're already overwhelmed, even the smallest decisions can feel complicated.


I remember when my boys were little and we traveled for Christmas. There was the pressure to find the perfect gifts, remember to pack everything, and then lug it all to someone else's house, where we'd spend days together. By the time Christmas was over, I felt like I'd run a marathon, and I'm not sure anyone realized how much work it had been.


Looking back, I wish I'd spent less time trying to make everything perfect and more time creating Christmas traditions for our own little family.


So, whether you're wondering if you can skip the gift exchange, decline an invitation, or show up with store-bought rolls, I've got answers to some of those holiday etiquette questions. And maybe a little permission to do things differently this year.


I've attended the same holiday party for years. Do I really need to RSVP?

Yes! Just because you've been invited every year doesn't mean your host should have to assume you're coming.


Even if it's your family's annual Christmas dinner, let them know you're coming. While you're at it, ask what you can bring.


Is it rude if I decline an invitation without giving a reason?


Is it rude if I decline an invitation without giving a reason?

I know the "no is a complete sentence" philosophy is popular right now, but I think we can do a little better when someone has been kind enough to invite us to an event.


Start by thanking your host for the invitation and expressing your regrets. If you feel comfortable sharing why you can't attend, go right ahead. Even something as simple as, "We've decided to have a quiet family night. The holidays have been so busy!" is perfectly reasonable. You don't need to offer a lengthy explanation.


If you can, suggest getting together another time. Lunch, coffee, or even a walk gives you a chance to spend time together without adding another holiday gathering to the calendar.


Is it rude if I ask who's coming to a holiday party before deciding whether to attend?


You might be asking out of genuine curiosity, but it can easily sound like you're sizing up the guest list to decide whether the party is worth your time or whether someone you'd rather avoid will be there. Either way, it's not a good look.


My advice is to accept or decline based on what you know about the party.


Is it rude if I don't bring a host gift to my friend's holiday party?


There are two occasions when I especially encourage bringing a host gift. The first is when you're visiting someone's home for the first time. The second is during the holidays.


Anyone willing to host during the busiest time of the year deserves a little something, even if it's a close friend whose home you visit regularly. It doesn't have to be expensive or elaborate. It's simply a way to say you appreciate the effort.


Here's a fun bit of etiquette history. In a radio program in the 1930s, the original Emily Post suggested that giving a host a gift could be considered a bribe for an invitation. My, how times have changed!


Is it rude if I bring store-bought food to a holiday gathering?

Goodness, no! Especially if cooking isn't your thing. Chocolates from a local candy store or rolls from your favorite bakery? Yes please!


Before deciding what to bring, ask your host if there's something specific you can contribute. And hosts, while it's perfectly fine to suggest a dish, please don't get too carried away. I've heard of hosts sending guests the exact recipe they expect them to follow. That's taking it way too far.


And if your host says, "Just bring yourself," know that they have the food and decorations covered. Just refer to my advice above before you arrive empty-handed.


Is it rude if I regift something I've received?

If you've ever opened a gift and immediately thought, "This would be perfect for so-and-so," you may have found the perfect opportunity to regift.


The key is to give something you genuinely believe the recipient will love, not simply something you're trying to get out of your house. Remember, you can always donate to a charity shop.


Here's how to regift the right way. Regift outside the circle where you originally received the gift. If your sister gave it to you, a coworker might be a better recipient than another family member. Make sure the item is unused and in its original condition, check for old gift receipts, and re-wrap the gift.


My favorite test is whether you'd be comfortable admitting the gift was regifted. If the thought makes you cringe, you might want to reconsider.


Is giving someone a gift card too impersonal?


A gift card can be a wonderful gift if you've put some thought into it. But let's be fair, they can also come across as a little lazy. Giving a vegetarian a gift card to a steakhouse probably won't win you any points for being thoughtful.


My boys give me gift cards to my favorite drink spot. Every time I stop for a drink, I think about what great gift-givers my boys are. They know what I enjoy, and that's what makes the gift special.


A gift card can be every bit as thoughtful as a wrapped present when you've taken the time to choose something the recipient will genuinely enjoy.


Is it rude for adults to share Christmas wish lists?

I'm not a fan of adults sending Christmas wish lists unless someone has asked for one. To me, it takes some of the thoughtfulness out of gift-giving.


I understand the appeal of lists. We want to give people something they'll actually use and enjoy. I'll happily take requests from my sons because I don't want to spend money on something that will end up collecting dust.


But I also think there's something special about choosing a gift based on what you know about someone. Their interests, their tastes, or something they mentioned wanting months ago. Isn't that part of the joy of gift-giving?


Is it rude if I suggest we skip exchanging gifts this year?

As I'm looking at the calendar, the holiday season, at least in my house, has already begun! Even I've started Christmas shopping. Trust me, that's a sure sign it's getting late.


ISo, while it's probably too late to change the gift exchange plans for this year, now is a great time to start the conversation about next Christmas.


My advice is to bring it up this Christmas, revisit it in the spring, and decide by the end of July.


If your family decides to skip the gift exchange, you're still welcome to give someone a little something. Just do it privately, outside the family gathering.


Traditions are wonderful, but there's nothing wrong with deciding it's time for a new one.


Is it rude if I stop sending Christmas cards?

You're under no obligation to send Christmas cards, even if you've been sending them for years or receive one from someone every December.


And this is coming from someone who has sent Christmas cards since high school and has a mailing list that's gotten ridiculously long over the years. Want to know how many cards I get in return? About five. Does that stop me? Not a chance.


I love the tradition, but I recognize that it takes time and money. If sending cards has become one more thing on your holiday to-do list that you're dreading, give yourself permission to let it go.


Can I ask someone not to post holiday photos of my children or me?

Just because you're happy to pose for a photo doesn't mean you want it shared on social media.


If someone is taking photos at a holiday gathering, it's perfectly reasonable to let them know you'd prefer that pictures of you or your children stay off social media. You don't need to explain your reasons.


And if you're the one taking photos, always ask permission before posting pictures of other people, especially children.


So, there you have it. A few answers to those holiday etiquette questions we sometimes hesitate to ask. Traditions can change, and so can our expectations of the holidays. Sometimes that's exactly what we need.


Of course, these aren't the only etiquette questions that come up during the holidays. If you've been wondering about one, I'd love to hear it. Chances are, someone else is wondering the same thing.


Need a delicious dish for the holidays? My free download, Holiday Recipes Worth Sharing, includes four recipes, one for Thanksgiving, one for a Christmas party, one for family Christmas and one to bring a little luck on New Year's Day. Subscribe to my email list to get your free copy.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page